When should you not buy a house?

There is some fancy about owning a house. For ages, a house has been considered the ‘best investment’. A house of your own happens to be a dream for most people.

There’s something emotional about it too. Your parents, your relatives, everyone recommends to buy a house.

“Khud ka ek ghar to hona hi chahiye” (You should have one home of your own).

And then you see those full page advertisements giving away fancy deals, offers that promise nothing less than heaven. The banks too are willing to give you loans at ‘easy EMIs‘.

Combine all this, you are willing to stretch yourself to any extent to get your dream home.

Knock, knock!

“Can we take a break please and look at some important issues?”

The other side of buying a house

Don’t buy a house because the full page advertisements tell you to buy as they entice you with their grand offers. They are thinking about themselves and their sales, not you. Not also because your friends, family and relatives are asking you to do it. Yes, they are acting out of concern and affection. Yet!

You have to think for yourself, your needs, your goals. Here are some pointers for you to think:

# Can you really afford it?

As it is, buying a house turns out be the first major borrowing decision. You will have to service your loan through EMIs every month. Look at your cash flow – the total of your EMIs (including home+car+others) should not exceed 40% of your take home salary.

What’s the logic? You will need money to take care of your monthly expenses, buy regular stuff and save for other needs too. If you have children you will need to pay for their tuition, etc.

Buying a house brings in other related expenses – broker fees, registration charges, stamp duty, municipal taxes, society maintenance, insurance, etc. Can your cash flows service them too?

# Are you ready for the downpayment?

While you can get the bank to finance 80% of the cost of buying a house, 20% of the cost has to be made as a downpayment. For example, if the house costs Rs. 70 lacs, the downpayment you need to make is going to be about Rs. 15 lacs. Is that money available with you? Can you take it out from your reserves without hurting your other goals?

# Is you emergency fund ready?

You should have sufficient liquidity available to you in emergency funds. It could be meeting regular expenses, if for any reason the cash inflow stops or for any unplanned expense that might arise. Once you are servicing an EMI, your emergency fund should provide for that too.

Typically, an emergency fund should have about 6 months of your monthly expenses including EMIs. Is your emergency fund ready for that?

# What’s your credit score?

Can you get a great deal on your loan – I mean the interest rate? If your credit score is not good, the bank may treat you as a riskier customer and charge you a higher rate of interest. Sometimes, a not so good credit report and score can lead to rejection of loan too.

You should have a credit score of close to 800 to be able to bargain for a lower interest rate.

Think about these points before you make a final decision.

Buying a house – when it is a no-no

  1. Do not buy property because everyone else, including your friends, colleagues and relatives, is also buying. Keep the emotions aside and think what is right for you in your situation, with the resources that you have.
  2. Carefully study the profile of the builder or developer of the property. Go with an A rated builder with a proven track record. It will benefit you to know that till date there is no regulation on real estate so you have little help available to protect yourself from greedy builders. If that is not the case, better stay away than suffer from poor quality construction, legal ownership issues, etc. (The Real Estate Bill is still stuck in the Indian Parliament.)
  3. Do not let a property purchase become a financial burden. You have to arrange for the down payment as well as service monthly EMIs. Take only as much loan, which will enable you to serve the EMI as well as leave enough for taking care of other, expenses plus emergency savings. A good thumb rule is that your EMI payment should not exceed 40% of your take home pay.
  4. Don’t be driven by FOMO – Fear of Missing Out. You think something like this – “oh, this is a great property. And the limited period offer is going to be over anytime. What if there is nothing left? Prices will rise and it will soon be unaffordable too. I should buy it now before it is over.” You see, you are deluding yourself emotionally. The worst financial decisions are made because of FOMO. Save yourself.
  5. Real estate suffers from illiquidity. There is no stock exchange where properties are bought and sold in an instant and you can get your money in a few days. Nor, can it be sold in parts. You can’t sell one room if you need some money. So do not block a large amount of your money in real estate.

Is it really a must to buy a house?

Societal wisdom would have you believe so. But there is another point of view. Don’t buy a house. Instead, focus on what matters to you.

Actually, it depends on what are your priorities?

I have a friend, who consciously stayed away from buying a house and accumulated money because he had a different priority. He wanted to startup on his own, build his own business. He stayed put through all the craziness surrounding him and finally today he is glad he has the money to bootstrap his startup.

For him, his goal of starting up was more important than putting money into an illiquid asset.

The question for you – Is buying a house a priority? Or, there are bigger life goals that I want to work towards.


Between you and me: Have you stayed away from buying a house? What factors do you put into consideration for making this decision of buying a house? As always, love to hear from you. Do post your comments.

6 thoughts on “When should you not buy a house?”

  1. I completely agree with this. My and wife and I always think that living on rent is a far better option in today’s time then buying a house and getting stuck with it. If you have to buy buy it as not a burden but just to diversify your money into a different asset class. And that too not by taking loans. Loans is negative compounding and you actually get negative returns in the end.

    I also read another article which said buying a house early in your life is a bad decision for your career.

    http://www.forbes.com/sites/ricksmith/2014/07/02/5-career-mistakes-you-will-regret-in-10-years/

  2. value investing is pretty important. houses don’t have as much utility as the price we are paying, they are not really an investment anymore. property prices are still not on equilibrium.. property prices can be considered as the part of bubble – ready to burst.. i guess, public is waiting for another 2008..
    I’d say, houses are a liability with monthly and yearly expense of maintenance.. even the loan taken spans for 20 – 30 years.. its value may rise – but you only build one house in life and it will be left for your children.. i don’t think i am ready for such a long term investment lol..
    Given that monthly rental is pretty low, and it gives an option to move to better locality as our income increases, i’d say living on rental is better option..
    Stoicism has better take on this, excess luxury would only enslave us.. a long term loan means a long term commitment to stay in the same shitty job and stable secure life without any room for risks(close to death)..

Comments are closed.